When Bert Mitchell remembers his motor-vehicle accident in February 2003, the 67-year-old can still see the two tractor-trailers jackknifed ahead of him on Highway 401, just north of Cobourg, Ont., where he lives. As Mitchell careened toward the pileup, there was a collision in his own mind — a split second of dissonance — between what he would attempt and what he couldn’t possibly avoid. He then stomped on the brake pedal as his Toyota Corolla was rear-ended by another tractor-trailer and driven into and under the stationary trucks just ahead. It took emergency responders several hours to free him from the wreckage — an extrication that he recalls only as scattered images witnessed amid brief moments of consciousness.
When Mitchell finally awoke from an induced coma two weeks later, he found himself in pain so excruciating that he thought he would pass out. The nurses were palpating his chest, clearing fluids from his collapsed lungs. “It’s like the old adage,” he says, still bemused. “I heard someone screaming and then realized it was me.” He was later told that he also had a concussion, 12 broken ribs, two spinal breaks and other internal injuries, as well as a compound fracture in his left arm.
Several weeks on a morphine drip at Toronto’s Sunnybrook Hospital led to several more weeks at Northumberland Hills Hospital in Cobourg. After finally being discharged, he remained bedridden for the better part of a year, completely dependent on a combination of the opioid pain-relief drugs OxyContin and Oxycocet.
“Taking these painkillers was very pleasant,” Mitchell admits. “The pain would return slowly, but I would take an OxyContin, and then five minutes later, everything was great again. It was a comforting feeling that would wash over my body with every heartbeat. I felt confident, secure — and happy.” OxyContin also made Mitchell drowsy. Although his midday snoozes were satisfying, he would fall asleep anywhere and at any time — even while behind the wheel of his car. After several near collisions, his wife, Sue, took over the bulk of their driving.
While recovering at home one day, Mitchell, who was forced to retire as a training technician because of his injuries, was shocked to read about the addictive nature of the drug that he had been taking for more than a year. He decided to stop cold turkey. “This was a mistake,” he says. “In just a few hours, I felt that something was very wrong.” As the drug’s effects started to wear off, the severe, intractable pain came back in waves until it was all-engulfing. He began to shake and panic. All he knew was that he had to have more OxyContin. It was “impossible to resist.”
While the prevailing picture of an opioid addict may be a street-involved person living in a place like Vancouver’s Downtown Eastside, a prescription from a family doctor can mark the beginning of a downward spiral into addiction. Mitchell is one of the growing number of North Americans — many elderly — who have overused pain medication in recent years, sometimes with tragic consequences. Opioids like OxyContin and fentanyl have long been prescribed for chronic conditions such as headaches and arthritis, and are highly recommended following surgery or at the end of life. But as opioid-related overdoses and deaths continue to increase, and as our aging population experiences aches and pains with ruthless regularity, physicians are being asked to pause before prescribing opioids to patients.
'What’s happened is that people are being prescribed opioids for more chronic, more persisting painful conditions, such as a nagging lower back, neck and leg after an automobile accident or a fall down the stairs. . . . And that sets up this cycle in which [a patient] always needs more.'
The seasons passed slowly, and Mitchell’s blissful haze wore thin. His accident-related pain now had merciful limits, but he often felt frustrated, even despairing. Determined to kick the addiction, he steeled himself for what was to come. “After four years, I finally went to my doctor and went through a program of gradual reduction of OxyContin and the eventual switch to fentanyl patches,” he says. “But after the first several months, I started becoming dependent on [fentanyl] and experienced insomnia, involuntary twitching and depression at the thought that I had lost control of my ability to function. . . . I was also tired of feeling a sense of panic whenever there was a chance that I couldn’t get my prescription refilled or if I thought that I had forgotten [the patches] while away from home.”
So after seven more years of gnawing uncertainty, Mitchell — who had no history of addiction prior to using OxyContin and fentanyl — decided to go off the opioids once and for all, without consulting his doctor. Only this time around, he inched forward, reducing his dosage by simply cutting the fentanyl patches in half, then in thirds and, finally, in quarters. After about two months, Mitchell says that he discontinued them altogether and felt completely, unmistakably “free.”
Dr. Hillel Finestone, the director of stroke rehabilitation research at Ottawa’s Élisabeth Bruyère Hospital and an associate professor of physical medicine and rehabilitation at the University of Ottawa, says that “people are finally realizing that there’s a high level of opioid prescriptions, with some physicians not being careful enough evaluating the drugs’ addictive potential.”
“What’s happened is that people are being prescribed opioids for more chronic, more persisting painful conditions, such as a nagging lower back, neck and leg after an automobile accident or a fall down the stairs,” he says. “And that sets up this cycle in which [a patient] always needs more.”
Finestone, who is also a fellow of the American Academy of Physical Medicine and Rehabilitation and author of the 2009 book The Pain Detective: Every Ache Tells a Story, points out that most opioid users aren’t recreational consumers “sitting in the corner of their living rooms, in the darkened night. . . . These are people dealing with their pain.”
Roughly one in five Canadians — and as many as three in five seniors — live with some kind of irrevocable suffering. According to the Canadian Centre on Substance Abuse (CCSA), nearly 15 percent of the general population and roughly 16 percent of seniors use pain relievers such as morphine, oxycodone (best known by the brand name OxyContin) and fentanyl (typically administered through an adhesive patch). In fact, Canada has become the world’s second-largest per capita consumer of opioids behind the United States. In 2015, the number of Canadian opioid prescriptions was 19 million, according to 2015 figures provided to the Globe and Mail by IMS Brogan, which monitors the health-care industry.
But opioids can also bring about drowsiness, perspiration, constipation, nausea, vomiting and a loss of appetite, the CCSA says. And higher doses can cause sleep apnea, mood changes and an overwhelming feeling of euphoria, as well as a significant decrease in one’s breathing rate, which can lead to unconsciousness and death. People who are physically dependent on opioids — addiction can happen in as little as a week — may also experience withdrawal symptoms in mere hours if they simply run out of medication or decide to quit abruptly. Think of it as a terrible flu. Insomnia and lower-back pain may kick in. Chills can race through the body. For a couple of days straight, there can be major diarrhea, vomiting or dry-heaving, and even more muscle aches. In other words, opioids may not relieve underlying pain as much as they numb the suffering associated with withdrawal.
As a result, opioid users may take a daily dose higher than what’s recommended by their doctor; ingest them together with alcohol or other sedatives; and beg or steal opioids from friends or relatives. Some addicts obtain prescriptions from multiple physicians without disclosing their other prescriptions — a scheme called “double doctoring” — or resort to using street- or Internet-purchased drugs, which aren’t regulated and are therefore far more dangerous.
Opioid poisoning increased by more than 40 percent between 2007 and 2015 in Canada. Photo by iStock.com/JamesBrey
The effect of opioids on Canada’s health-care system is no less adverse.
According to 2016 figures from the Canadian Institute for Health
Information (CIHI) and the CCSA, opioid poisoning increased by more than
40 percent between 2007 and 2015. Across the country, hospitals
recorded nearly 4,800 admissions for opioid overdoses in 2014, compared
to nearly 3,400 in 2007. The CIHI and the CCSA reported that those
patients stayed in hospital for an average of eight days, which is
longer than patients recovering from pneumonia, heart attacks or hip
Last April, British Columbia even declared a public
health emergency because of opioid-related deaths. By year’s end, the
province’s coroners service announced, 914 people had died from
overdosing on an illicit drug — usually fentanyl — a nearly 80 percent
increase from 2015.
Across the provincial border in Alberta, 338
died due to opioid-related overdoses between January and September of
last year. In Ontario, opioid overdoses are now the third leading cause
of accidental death, killing two people in the province every day,
according to data provided to CBC News by the Office of the Chief
Coroner in October.
In 2015, one year after he finally got off
fentanyl, Bert Mitchell’s appendix ruptured, forcing him to undergo
emergency surgery. Once again, he spent a number of days in the hospital
and was placed on a morphine pump for his pain management. Upon
discharge, Mitchell — already stupefied by painkillers — was advised by
his surgeon to take opioids. He objected strenuously, though, informing his
physician that “under no circumstances” would he ever take something
like OxyContin again.
“I was aware that I was addicted to
OxyContin once and that I would be susceptible,” he says. “[My surgeon]
said that he understood my trepidation and indicated that he would
prescribe Percocet instead. But when I went to the pharmacy to fill the
prescription, my pharmacist was visibly shocked. He knew of my bout with
OxyContin and fentanyl because he filled my prescriptions during my
recovery. He told me that Percocet was the same thing as OxyContin.”
contains far less oxycodone and is not as long lasting. Still,
Mitchell’s pharmacist felt that the prescription was inappropriate for
him and called Mitchell’s surgeon to express his concern.
doctor not even realize?” Mitchell asks. “This would seem to indicate
that some doctors who are involved with pain management aren’t aware of
what — and to whom — they are prescribing.”
Derived from poppies,
opium has long been the elixir for pain. The ancient Sumerians are
believed to have been the first to discover the flower’s euphoric
properties around 3,400 BC; they called it “the joy plant.” In the early
1800s, German pharmacist apprentice Friedrich Sertürner separated the
sleep-inducing compound from the poppy plant and named it morphine,
after the Greek god of dreams.
In 1874, British chemist Alder
Wright synthesized the drug that would come to be known as heroin. And
by the turn of the 20th century, physicians didn’t prescribe much other
than opiates for pain.
“Thus, addiction exploded — to a drug that
people believed was safe because doctors said so,” Sam Quinones writes
in his 2015 book Dreamland: The True Tale of America’s Opiate Epidemic.
“By 1996 American physicians were tenderized to accepting opiates for
chronic pain. Undertreated pain was an epidemic and physicians now had
the duty, the calling, to relieve it using the new tools and drugs the
pharmaceutical companies were inventing.” During that same period, “pain
crusaders” even heralded Purdue Pharma’s new synthetic drug, OxyContin,
as “the Holy Grail,” Quinones points out.
This “happy façade
covered a disturbing reality” in the United States, Quinones writes:
addiction has devastated the Rust and Bible belts, as well as other
parts of the country. More than 15,000 Americans died of prescription
opioid overdoses in 2015, according to the Centers for Disease Control
and Prevention. That’s more than the total number of deaths caused by
heroin or cocaine overdoses.
But there is a misconception surrounding
who is most at risk of abusing opioids, according to Andrew Kolodny,
the executive director of Physicians for Responsible Opioid Prescribing
in the United States. In August 2015, Kolodny told Al Jazeera America
that the rate of opioid abuse may be even higher among older Americans
who receive prescriptions. “When you look at the groups that have had
the greatest increase in problems associated with prescription opioids —
for example, visits to hospital emergency rooms because of opioid
misuse — it’s Americans over 65,” he said.
CDC data published in
2015 revealed that over 3.6 million Americans aged 60 and older used
prescription opioids in a 30-day period. Between 2014 and 2015, the rate
of Americans over the age of 65 who died from synthetic opioid
overdoses increased by 25 percent.
Still, their opioid
addiction remains a hidden epidemic, Kolodny told Al Jazeera. That’s
because family members, friends and caretakers frequently miss the
telltale signs of addiction. When an older person overdoses on
prescription opioids before going to sleep, the cause of death is far
too often listed as “natural.”
'When it comes to a complex pain patient, (a) prescription pad is only going to do so much.'
Pain experts in both Canada and the United States say that there’s still
a place for opioids in health care, such as after a major surgery. And
the risk of long-term opioid use in surgical patients is extremely low,
according to Dr. Hance Clarke, the medical director of Toronto General
Hospital’s pain research unit. Clarke led a study, published in the
journal JAMA Surgery last August, about the use of post-surgery
painkillers over one year. The 39,140 participants were 66 and older,
had not taken opioids in at least a year and underwent major surgery
between 2003 and 2010. The study suggested that opioid abuse occurred in
less than half of one percent of the 20,744 seniors who received
opioids after their surgery. The rest only briefly used drugs like
OxyContin or Percocet.
“If you’re an elderly patient and you
come into the hospital [for surgery] and have no chronic pain issue, the
fact that you’re going to be on opioids short-term is probably not
going to be an issue for you,” says Clarke.
While he says that
there is “excellent evidence” that opioids can effectively treat acute
pain after surgery, he admits that when it comes to a complex pain
patient, his “prescription pad is only going to do so much.”
agrees. Opioids should never be the “mainstream treatment of pain,” he
says. However, often “family physicians have few other treatment options
He suggests non-pharmacological therapies,
including physiotherapy, kinesiology and psychological counselling, as
well as holistic practices like mindfulness. But these may not be
covered by provincial health insurance and assistance plans. So the
major impediment to receiving this “total basket of care,” according to
Finestone, is “the financial hardship that’s imposed on individuals if
they pay for all of these services, which can cost tens of thousands of
dollars over time.”
He says that policy-makers and health-care
practitioners must also come together to turn the tide of opioid
over-prescription while keeping pain levels under control. This means a
team approach similar to that established for cancer, stroke and heart
patients, who are treated not only by physicians and nurses, but also by
social workers, dietitians and physiotherapists. There’s virtue in this
multidisciplinary care, he says. Both money and lives are saved.
Finestone worries about what will happen to patients if they’re forced
to suddenly withdraw from their painkillers. “What do you do when your
family doctor finally wants to stop prescribing opioids, but you still
need them because of the powerful physiological and psychological
dependency?” he asks. “You can’t just be told, ‘Tough luck.’” In the
absence of affordable opioid-substitution treatment and cognitive
behavioural therapy, Finestone says pain sufferers may go straight from
the pharmacy to the black market for their medication, instead of
weaning off it altogether.
In his 2014 book, Being Mortal: Medicine and What Matters in the End,
American surgeon and public health researcher Atul Gawande describes
the human struggle “to cope with the constraints of our biology, with
the limits set by genes and cells and flesh and bone.”
“If to be human is to be limited, then the role of caring professions
and institutions — from surgeons to nursing homes — ought to be aiding
people in their struggle with those limits. Sometimes, we can offer a
cure, sometimes only a salve, sometimes not even that. But whatever we
can offer, our interventions, and the risks and sacrifices they entail,
are justified only if they serve the larger aims of a person’s life.
When we forget that, the suffering we inflict can be barbaric. When we
remember it the good that we do can be breathtaking.”
At 67, Bert
Mitchell no longer embodies the downward spiral of opioids. Instead, he
gives physical shape to a clean-living philosophy. In hindsight, the
reason he first used the drugs oscillated somewhere between the
avoidance of pain and the permanence of pleasure. Mitchell sympathizes
with seniors who want to use opioids, especially if they’re in a lot of
pain. He understands how they could “accept an inevitable addiction over
a miserable existence.” As for people who are closer to retirement age
and younger, he says that if they require opioids, every effort should
be taken to control their dose and duration — “two or three days
Today, Mitchell and his wife spend most of their time
between their sun-drenched condo in Bonita Springs, Fla., and their
three-bedroom bungalow in Cobourg. He plays 18 holes of golf whenever he
feels well enough and remains active as a vice-president in the Retired
Workers’ Chapter of the province’s Power Workers’ Union. The couple
have always travelled, but in recent years they have taken trips to
Mexico, the Caribbean, Hawaii and the French Polynesian islands.
course, Mitchell’s friends and family still ask him, “How are you feeling?” They know he still suffers from post-accident pain: the arthritic soreness and the scar tissue-related
stiffness. But he says that he’d rather be this way than addicted to
“this [opioid] crap.” In fact, he barely uses any medications, other
than the occasional Advil or Naproxen and drugs for blood pressure and
cholesterol. He opts instead for massages and “regular dips” in a hot
“Yes, I’m feeling much better today,” Mitchell says, rather assuredly. “I finally have my life back.”