UC Observer logo
UCObserver on SoundCloud UCObserver on YouTube UCObserver on Facebook UCObserver on Twitter UCObserver's RSS Feeds

Five reasons to fear that the death penalty isn’t, well, dead

By Pieta Woolley


Here in Canada, the death penalty was abolished by Parliament in July, 1976 — exactly 40 years ago this summer. Then-Prime Minister Pierre Trudeau’s speech helped push through the close vote, at a time when most Canadians favoured capital punishment. Apart from Louis Riel’s famous execution by hanging in 1885, try naming one of the 710 Canadians put to death between 1867 and 1976. Indeed, 40 years is a long time ago.

What’s more, Prime Minister Justin Trudeau declared this February that Canada will no longer let citizens sit on death rows in other countries. So all of this can make it feel as though the death penalty is becoming historical — something that ignorant people used to do, but modern, educated people eschew outside countries like the United States. Certainly, as Alicia von Stomwitz points out in her Observer interview with Dead Man Walking author Sister Helen Prejean, there’s plenty to reject about the death penalty — especially if you’re a Christian.

Realistically, though, just because Canada doesn’t condone the death penalty presently doesn’t mean it won’t ever come back. Here are five reasons to fear that the death penalty isn’t really dead in Canada.

1. Most Canadians favour it

In July 2016, Abacus Data released a poll that shows 58 percent of Canadians and 59 percent of Americans believe that the death penalty is morally acceptable. Considering that the two countries have opposite approaches to the death penalty (it’s illegal in Canada, and legal and common in the U.S.), the moral similarity stings. Perhaps, though, if Canadians were actively executing prisoners, we would lose our stomach for it.

2. If Quebec separates, even more Canadians will favour it

Just 51 percent of Quebecers say they find the death penalty morally acceptable. That relatively low number depresses the pan-Canadian statistic of 58 percent. Sadly, Abacus didn’t release full regional results for the poll. But it reported that 63 percent of Albertans approve of the death penalty. So if Quebec separates, Parliament may find itself representing a population that overwhelmingly approves of the death penalty.

3. Emerging far right governments love it


Philippines President Rodrigo Duterte’s “tough on crime” campaign promise has resulted in nearly 1,000 executions of drug suspects by police in just three months. North Korea’s Kim Jong Un has reportedly executed 70 people since 2011 — seven times as many as his predecessor. And in the U.S., Republican presidential hopeful Donald Trump, who has rarely mentioned the death penalty during his campaign, has strongly supported it in the past. Today, there are nearly 3,000 prisoners are on death row in America. Since January, 15 people have been executed by lethal injecting in the country.

Though the overall number of countries actively executing prisoners has plummeted to just 58, the swing to the right internationally doesn’t bode well for the trend.

4. 1976 didn’t kill it in Parliament — or in the media

Ending the death penalty in Canada took decades; the first Parliamentary attempt was in 1914. Similarly, reintroducing it may take decades and multiple efforts. In 1987, the House of Commons narrowly voted down a bill that would have reintroduced the death penalty. In 2012, the National Post’s letters editor asked if it was time to bring back the death penalty, and many wrote in to support it. Among the letters was this fairly representative snippet by Toronto’s Ron Fawcett: “Our permissive society has created an environment of violence and fear, marked by teenage rioting, sexual predation and brutal killings. Bringing back the death penalty for serial killers and those who kill women and children is the right thing to do.”

5. The usual pro-life arguments against it are not atheist-friendly 


Leaders in the anti-death movement have been Catholic for the most part — consider both Pierre Trudeau and Sister Helen Prejean. In the U.S., self-identified Christians are far less likely than “average” Americans to support the death penalty. Furthermore, Christian Millennials are half as likely (just 32 percent) than the average to support capital punishment. But the arguments of the sacredness of human life, the judgement of God and the commandment to not kill may not have much impact among non-Christians. So as religious affiliation continues to decline, will the appetite for capital punishment indeed surge?


Author's photo
Pieta Woolley is a writer in Powell River, B.C.
Readers’ advisory: The discussion below is moderated by The UC Observer and facilitated by Intense Debate (ID), an online commentary system. The Observer reserves the right to edit or reject any comment it deems to be inappropriate. Approved comments may be further edited for length, clarity and accuracy, and published in the print edition of the magazine. Please note: readers do not need to sign up with ID to post their comments on ucobserver.org. We require only your user name and e-mail address. Your comments will be posted from Monday to Friday between 9:30 a.m. and 5:30 p.m. Join the discussion today!
Promotional Image

Editorials

David Wilson%

Observations

by David Wilson

Enclaves of the elderly

Promotional Image

Video

ObserverDocs: A shoulder to lean on

by Observer Staff

Sheima Benembarek was born in Saudi Arabia, grew up in Morocco and moved to Canada in 2005. In 2015, she relocated to Toronto. At first, the city seemed so much bigger, impersonal — and even threatening — until a fateful encounter in the subway one day.

Promotional Image

Faith

January 2017

Presbytery turns down bid to halt Vosper hearing

by Mike Milne

World

February 2017

Many faces, one humanity

by Wade Davis

The words and photographs of the Canadian author and explorer capture the richness — and fragility — of global cultures and rituals

Society

February 2017

An anatomy of hate

by Douglas Tindal

It’s on the rise everywhere. The writer explores our most troubling emotion and asks how we might overcome it.

World

February 2017

Many faces, one humanity

by Wade Davis

The words and photographs of the Canadian author and explorer capture the richness — and fragility — of global cultures and rituals

Society

January 2017

The new agrarians

by Lois Ross

In the next 15 years, almost half of Canadian farms will change hands. Meet seven millennials who view agriculture as a career — and moral calling.

Faith

March 2016

The Walrus Talks Spirituality

by Observer Staff

Promotional Image